If you have read Basics4Mac for a while, you will know that I am somewhat of a fanatic when it comes to making backups. (Basics4Mac articles on backups) I back up the iMac using Time Machine and I back up my MacBook to two different hard drives using SuperDuper. Important documents get stored on the iDisk.
A while back I wrote a brief article on off-site backup and that got me thinking. The iDisk is great for small amounts of data, but it is limited to 20 gig in size. Taking a backup hard drive to an off-site location works fine, but is definitely not an automatic process. When I think about my most important and precious data, my iPhoto Library comes to mind first. Many types of lost data can be recreated, but I can't go back in time to retake lost photos.
Since I have plenty of local backups of my data, I decided that for myself, an automatic off-site backup would be for "catastrophic" situations: fire, burglary, tornado, etc where my computer equipment was lost, including all of my local backups.
In this article, I am going to give some general information about automatic off-site backups and then discuss three automatic off-site backup systems useful for large amounts of data such as your iPhoto Library.
Let's start with some common elements of automatic off-site backups:
Off-site backups usually go to a data center maintained by the company that provides the backup software. The company should give you some idea of how that data center is set up to give you an idea of how reliable your data storage will be.
Since data centers are expensive to build and maintain, there is a charge for using the backup service. Some charge just for the storage space you use, others charge for both the storage and data transfer.
Your data is encrypted before it leaves your computer so that no one on the "other side" can view your data.
Your data is also compressed before it leaves your computer. Compression helps speed up the data transfer and reduces storage charges.
Backing up to an off-site location can take a very long time, even with a fast internet connection. If you are uploading large amounts of data, the first backup could take weeks.
You can choose which files and folders you want to back up and which ones to exclude.
Backups are incremental. While it can take a very long time to get the first back up made, subsequent backup sessions are much shorter because only changed data is sent.
Backing up happens in the background on your computer so it doesn't interrupt your work. Much of the transferring happens when you aren't actively using your computer. This causes some special issues for notebook users who typically put their notebook to sleep when not using it. If you are using a notebook Mac, you will need to leave it awake while you aren't using it while that first backup is happening.
And now a look at three automatic off-site backup systems:
Mozy HomeMozy is the cheapest and most basic of the plans I am looking at here. For $5US a month per computer, you can backup and store an unlimited amount of data to its servers. Mozy didn't impress me as I did my own testing and research. There is no information about its data center on their website. I found that it sometimes took a couple of days to recognize some changes to my hard drive. I also read accounts online of people having problems with restored data from Mozy. Your backup is only as good as its ability to restore your data.
Jungle Disk with Amazon S3Jungle Disk is the big dog of off-site backup. Amazon S3 has multiple data centers around the world. Jungle Disk has many advanced features that the others don't. It also costs twice as much or more to backup and store your data. I would recommend Jungle Disk to anyone who relies on their data for their livelihood, a professional photographer or film maker for example. For home use, I found Jungle Disk to be overkill.
CrashPlanCrashPlan is similar to Mozy, but has many compelling features that Mozy does not offer. CrashPlan comes in two versions, a free and a paid version. The free version shows advertisements but they only show up in the CrashPlan software itself and they are very unobtrusive. The paid version (called CrashPlan+) has a few more options like continuous backups and no ads. Here are two of the features of CrashPlan the I found so compelling:
You can upload your data to their data center, which they call CrashPlan Central. They go into great detail on their website about their data center. Backing up to CrashPlan Central costs $0.10US per gig per month with a $5 minimum. That $5 minimum gives you 50 gig of storage which is a good sized iPhoto Library. Since uploading all of your data could take weeks, CrashPlan Central allows you to send them a hard drive containing your backup data and they will copy it locally, thereby skipping all of the upload time. If you need a quick restore, they will also (for a fee) send you a hard drive in the mail with your data on it.
You can upload your data to a friend's computer across the internet. This is the online equivalent of swapping hard drives with a friend. There is no backup and storage fee if you backup to a friend's computer. Your friend can use the excess space on their own hard drive, or you can give them a hard drive of your backed up data that they connect to their computer. If you need a full restore, you can simply get the hard drive back from your friend. I set my mother up to back up her iPhoto Library onto a PC that gets very little use that we have in the basement. Setting this up is easy, but it took a little bit of messing around to get a connection from her Macbook in Illinois to my PC in Indiana.
For additional details about all three services, I have put together a table showing the features of each. Click here to view
NOTE: If you are using off-site backup as a catastrophic backup plan, only back up your home folder, or certain parts of your home folder. Backing up the Mac OS X operating system and all of your applications will only increase your transfer time and increase your storage costs. After a catastrophe, you will likely need a new Mac anyway which will come with Mac OS X and as far as applications go, they can be replaced. (storing your software license keys in a file stored off-site will make replacing your applications easier.)
After all of my research and testing, here is what I ended up with on my computer system at home: My entire home folder of the MacBook and iMac are being backed up to CrashPlan Central. I expect that to cost me around $10/month. My mother is also storing her iPhoto Library on my unused PC hard drive. This is costing nothing for us on either end. While storing irreplaceable data to my basement PC is nowhere as secure as backing up to an underground data center, my mother and I both decided that if there were a catastrophe large enough to wipe out all our our computers in two different states, that we would have worse problems on our hands than worrying about the loss of photos.
Automatic off-site backup can seem a bit intimidating to set up, but it really isn't that bad. Of the three services that I looked at, all had extensive setup and help information on their websites. With a bit of research and a lot of patience for that first backup, you too can protect the photos, movies and music that you hold dear.
Nice article and comparison chart, Chris! I just wanted to add a couple of notes on the comparison chart. If you're backing up to CrashPlan Central with CrashPlan (free version), backup occurs hourly. Backing up to your own destinations with CrashPlan (free version) is once daily. Also, both CrashPlan and CrashPlan+ support unlimited versions.
Authored by: Anonymous on
Thursday, February 26 2009
Great chart! A few extra corrections/points on CrashPlan
1. CrashPlan is once per hour, not once per day.
2. CrashPlan versioning supports an unlimited # of versions for unlimited period of time.
3. You have 3 options for restore- Online using client, web restore using browser, and we'll also ship you your data on a hard drive if you need it all back asap.
4. CrashPlan has better compression than either - this means less bandwidth, disk, and ultimately, less transfer time for backup.
5. Both productions support backing up to an attached disk, online, and off-site to a friend. We're the only one that doesn't have a single point of failure. What if Amazon S3 is down? (It was down for hours last year!) Google Mail was recently down too. All services go down, it's just a matter of time.
Anyway - awesome job - you really captured some key differentiators.
crash plan looks so simple - i am inclined to use it, but i am a professional photographer (boutique portrait studio) and do not want to take any chances with backing up my photos. i have moved my iphoto library (mostly personal photos) to external hard drive in order to free up space on my MAC, and only keep my professional photos on same external. but now all photos are only on this one external, hence the desire to back up online as well as I live in CA near wildfire areas. ALSO have additional external that is hooked up to MAC and using Time Machine, but now that iPhoto is moved off computer, don't think Time Machine will be backing up iPhoto. Need to be assured that I am backing up all photos in more than one place. could also do a duplicate external of the one that I am keeping all photos on now. and looking into Drobo. SO~ is crash plan the right place for me ? any suggestions? THANKS so much - your website is so helpful!
I've been using Crash Plan for several months now and am quite happy with it. I have not (thankfully) had to use it to restore, but one of the things I like most about Crash Plan is that if you need a quick restore, they will copy your data to a hard drive and mail it to you.
The Drobo looks like a cool idea and probably worth investigating as well, but I have to say, I feel _so_ much more relaxed about my backups having a good one off site.... way off site in the case of Crash Plan.
Authored by: Anonymous on
Tuesday, September 01 2009
so you are saying crash plan is ideal because it is an off-site option. i agree so far and it seems to be that crash plan will automatically backup from now on? (but it is taking forever for it to backup my computer!) =) problem is that all my photos are on separate externals which are therefore not being backed up by crash plan. so how do i back them up?
I also have put iPhoto library on these same two different externals - how can I automatically back up these two externals to match each other? i use a separate external for time machine, so these two i keep my photos on are not using time machine. thanks.
Authored by: Anonymous on
Tuesday, September 01 2009
i can set up crash plan to back up the externals AND the desktop? great! does it explain how on their website? any suggestions on how to have one external back up the other?
Shopping online? You can help support Basics4Mac by making your Amazon purchases through this website. Any purchases you make at Amazon by going through this site will give me a small commission. It does not affect the price of the items you buy. Click the link below to get started.
Renee Schaefer
CrashPlan